A blog devoted to professional aspects of design
and engineering applied to the art of fine woodworking.
July 1, 2014
More Behind the Not Yet Finished Method
My previous post about completing a project that would find itself yet unfinished because it was now functionally being used to produce new outcomes got me thinking about a segment of the population that finds itself bothered by my apparent inability to complete certain projects that I start. This population segment believes that you finish what you start regardless.
That segment should take a closer look at my blog entries before coming to conclusions that do not fit the direction I take with some of the projects that I classify as learning projects. Learning projects to me are those that teach something about a process or technique that I want to try before applying it to a more critical design whose outcome really matters. Like one commissioned by a client.
Take my shelving unit project for instance. I began building that project to evaluate where my workshop stood in its ability to produce larger projects after having built smaller studio projects for so long. I was able to see and correct deficiencies in shop layout and equipment as a result. That project was interrupted by the last one that happened to be paid for by a client, but not before its important outcomes had concluded.
The current speaker system project now making its way through my workshop is another example of a learning project that originally began as an opportunity to try a new dovetail jig which I again used in building the most recent client based project. I restarted that speaker project now as a way to fill in some free time before I possibly return to the much larger shelving unit project. That is if the shelving unit project proves beneficial to my current workshop goals.
Learning projects are great. I encourage anyone to try them when resources allow. There is no rush to finish something that proves its value in what it teaches once that teachable moment is understood, and can be further applied. I do though usually finish all projects that I start. Eventually.
June 22, 2014
The Pluralists: Where Design Inspiration Comes From
I build musical instruments, and so I care about good sound. I started to design and build my own speaker systems a number of years back. They have occasionally sold through local galleries. I started to build a set over a year ago that was based on a small full range driver. Small but with an incredible sound especially if supported by a subwoofer. This project is next on my list to complete.
The boxes are built using through dovetail joinery. A whole lot of different woods are used in their construction, so I came up with the name Pluralists.
The legsets are going to be something altogether different. I know a university graduate student who decided a couple of winters ago to make not a snowman, but a snow bear. She posted photos.
I was in the shop making small light fixtures at that time when I combined one of the fixtures with one of the Pluralist speaker boxes. I stood back to look at it and thought, snow bear.
The boxes are built using through dovetail joinery. A whole lot of different woods are used in their construction, so I came up with the name Pluralists.
The legsets are going to be something altogether different. I know a university graduate student who decided a couple of winters ago to make not a snowman, but a snow bear. She posted photos.
I was in the shop making small light fixtures at that time when I combined one of the fixtures with one of the Pluralist speaker boxes. I stood back to look at it and thought, snow bear.
The Molly Project: Completed But Not Finished
Sometime last year I decided that I wanted to build another pipe organ. Something happened to further reinvent that goal when I was recently approached to do a project for a friend who had started an indie folk band with her boyfriend.
Her name is Molly. She uses her background as a professional dancer to provide their music with percussion through dance. His name is Chase, and he is a music teacher with the public school system here in Minneapolis.
Molly approached me with a completely unique idea, and asked me what I thought about building a portable hollow box that could act as a combination dance floor and percussion device during their recording and performance sessions.
We talked over a lot of potential design criteria, and basically settled on the following.
I completed the project this past weekend. The band now has percussion provided through dance. The band is called THE SUMMER COATS, and they are writing and recording their own music. I am excited to hear their first songs, and in addition, equally excited for them as they plan their first tour in July.
This project for me is similar to building a pipe organ in that although my part of it is competed, the project itself is not finished. It now will do something that maybe hasn't been done in some way before. It will provide listeners with a unique musical experience. That is what is so great about building a functional object no matter what it is. That it will be used to do something. That something in this case is to make new music.
Her name is Molly. She uses her background as a professional dancer to provide their music with percussion through dance. His name is Chase, and he is a music teacher with the public school system here in Minneapolis.
Molly approached me with a completely unique idea, and asked me what I thought about building a portable hollow box that could act as a combination dance floor and percussion device during their recording and performance sessions.
We talked over a lot of potential design criteria, and basically settled on the following.
- The top had to be made of oak for its resonant qualities.
- The box had to be as light as possible so that Molly could help move it from place to place.
- The box had to reflect my standards of fine woodworking.
- The box had to have an access hole for a microphone.
I completed the project this past weekend. The band now has percussion provided through dance. The band is called THE SUMMER COATS, and they are writing and recording their own music. I am excited to hear their first songs, and in addition, equally excited for them as they plan their first tour in July.
This project for me is similar to building a pipe organ in that although my part of it is competed, the project itself is not finished. It now will do something that maybe hasn't been done in some way before. It will provide listeners with a unique musical experience. That is what is so great about building a functional object no matter what it is. That it will be used to do something. That something in this case is to make new music.
June 3, 2014
Panel Glue Press: An Argument for Calculated Risk
This blog is devoted to the professional aspects of design and engineering applied to the art of fine woodworking. I make that statement in its header. The entries are written to describe the evolution of engineering that I employ increasingly to design and build functional objects primarily from wood.
Today someone referenced a short story written years ago by Arthur C. Clark. You could say that it argues against the desire that a lot of us have to employ any advancement in technology to achieve better results as we engineers often do.
Clark's short story can be found here.
My last entry was about the time I just took from a client project to assemble a new panel glue press that promised to produce wide panels that came out of the press flat rather than more typically bowed. I took a risk by taking time from that client project to build something that promised a better result. Yet I had no experience with gluing panels with this method or tool. It could have worked against me, but tonight I found that it worked for me. The panel shown here in the glue press is perfectly flat across its width.
I am not afraid to attempt something new with risk involved when I think that the probability of that risk is worth the potential result gained by taking it. Failure has to be an option though because sometimes failure occurs. But I feel that an opportunity for success is often worth the risk taken if you do your homework, and trust yourself, your experience, and your skill set. It all came out well in this case.
Today someone referenced a short story written years ago by Arthur C. Clark. You could say that it argues against the desire that a lot of us have to employ any advancement in technology to achieve better results as we engineers often do.
Clark's short story can be found here.
My last entry was about the time I just took from a client project to assemble a new panel glue press that promised to produce wide panels that came out of the press flat rather than more typically bowed. I took a risk by taking time from that client project to build something that promised a better result. Yet I had no experience with gluing panels with this method or tool. It could have worked against me, but tonight I found that it worked for me. The panel shown here in the glue press is perfectly flat across its width.
I am not afraid to attempt something new with risk involved when I think that the probability of that risk is worth the potential result gained by taking it. Failure has to be an option though because sometimes failure occurs. But I feel that an opportunity for success is often worth the risk taken if you do your homework, and trust yourself, your experience, and your skill set. It all came out well in this case.
June 2, 2014
Panel Glue Press: The Reluctant Project
I am currently in the middle of a rather interesting project that requires two rather wide panels produced from rather thin stock relative to their width. This project therefore justifies the acquisition of a panel glue press clamping system shown here in the photo. The experienced woodworker will know that wide panels are rather difficult to glue up without having them bow across their width due to uneven clamping pressure applied by typical bar clamps even when those clamps are alternated on both sides of the panel during the glue up process.
I call the project to build a panel glue press a reluctant project because I rushed the production of its large supporting frame through the workshop. I rushed it because even though it will support a client commissioned project, it impacts the timeline for that client commissioned project which in this case just luckily happened to be slightly ahead of schedule.
But if the client based project happens to go south as projects sometimes will, then I may need that extra margin which now is no longer available because I spent it on building the new panel glue press. I think that every woodworker I know who operates his or her organization within any sort of business model must often make workshop upgrades within the time allotted to client based projects without seriously impacting the timeline for those projects. This is often difficult to do.
I rushed through the panel glue press project to minimize the impact it had on an ongoing client based project even though it ultimately improves the quality outcome of that project. The glue press frame turned out well, but with minor flaws that could have been avoided if I had taken more time to complete it with greater care and patience.
I find it somewhat difficult to balance that tradeoff between making a workshop change to benefit a client based project against the time it takes to effect that change though in the end, I usually value a better design or build outcome at the expense of the client project timeline. Communication with the client is very important in this instance. Some people will understand, want a better outcome, and tolerate a minor delay. Some though will emphasize the importance of schedule despite the fact that their project has durable value.
I call the project to build a panel glue press a reluctant project because I rushed the production of its large supporting frame through the workshop. I rushed it because even though it will support a client commissioned project, it impacts the timeline for that client commissioned project which in this case just luckily happened to be slightly ahead of schedule.
But if the client based project happens to go south as projects sometimes will, then I may need that extra margin which now is no longer available because I spent it on building the new panel glue press. I think that every woodworker I know who operates his or her organization within any sort of business model must often make workshop upgrades within the time allotted to client based projects without seriously impacting the timeline for those projects. This is often difficult to do.
I rushed through the panel glue press project to minimize the impact it had on an ongoing client based project even though it ultimately improves the quality outcome of that project. The glue press frame turned out well, but with minor flaws that could have been avoided if I had taken more time to complete it with greater care and patience.
I find it somewhat difficult to balance that tradeoff between making a workshop change to benefit a client based project against the time it takes to effect that change though in the end, I usually value a better design or build outcome at the expense of the client project timeline. Communication with the client is very important in this instance. Some people will understand, want a better outcome, and tolerate a minor delay. Some though will emphasize the importance of schedule despite the fact that their project has durable value.
May 9, 2014
Functional Design and Unintended Consequences
I often design something for one purpose only to have it used for something quite different than that for which it was originally intended. My recent drop leaf drawer unit design has taken that familiar path. I added a drop leaf top to a drawer unit that I had built so that I could use it from the couch as a laptop workstation or alternative dinner table. It spends its time these days doing none of that though.
I have a comfortable leather office chair that sees a lot more use lately because the drop leaf drawer unit that sits beside it now features one of my iPad stands placed atop it. The iPad is held at a perfect viewing angle and height for me while I sit on that leather chair.
The drop leaf extension added to the drawer unit can support my laptop without interfering with the iPad stand while located on the center of the table top. I can use the iPad to look up reference information while using the laptop for design work, a very efficient, compact, and comfortable work solution ergonomically integrating multiple resources which I had not originally intended to combine.
I like functional design not only for its ability to provide solutions to known problem requirements, but also for its ability to open new doors to creativity by providing unintended solutions. I saw this in the pipe organs I built where players with different musical backgrounds would use innovative stop registrations to perform music in ways I had not considered.
More often, we who build things will come up with a unique idea and get the you-cannot-do-it-that-way-because-it-has-never-been-done-before argument back in return. It is refreshing when a design is actually used to do something that has never been done before by someone who is willing to experience things in a fresh, new way.
I have a comfortable leather office chair that sees a lot more use lately because the drop leaf drawer unit that sits beside it now features one of my iPad stands placed atop it. The iPad is held at a perfect viewing angle and height for me while I sit on that leather chair.
The drop leaf extension added to the drawer unit can support my laptop without interfering with the iPad stand while located on the center of the table top. I can use the iPad to look up reference information while using the laptop for design work, a very efficient, compact, and comfortable work solution ergonomically integrating multiple resources which I had not originally intended to combine.
I like functional design not only for its ability to provide solutions to known problem requirements, but also for its ability to open new doors to creativity by providing unintended solutions. I saw this in the pipe organs I built where players with different musical backgrounds would use innovative stop registrations to perform music in ways I had not considered.
More often, we who build things will come up with a unique idea and get the you-cannot-do-it-that-way-because-it-has-never-been-done-before argument back in return. It is refreshing when a design is actually used to do something that has never been done before by someone who is willing to experience things in a fresh, new way.
April 30, 2014
The Molly Project: Iterations
The Molly Project is an attempt to build a tap dance floor that can be used as a percussive device during the performance of live music by building the floor upon a hollow yet enclosed box.
Molly is a singer and dancer in addition to being both friend and in this case client. One of her requirements is that the floor must be as light as possible yet built to minimum dimensions with certain materials that will enhance its resonant qualities.
My first design iteration had the box constructed of four side aprons joined to corner posts using mortise and tenon joinery. I was doing projects with that construction technique lately so it was natural to begin the design there. But that is not how a box is typically built.
The first true box iteration I explored was based on box joint construction. I built a couple of drawers and a few audio speaker system boxes using that method. I sometimes think of it as a signature style. But I think I am going to settle on another method that has worked well for me in the past. That method is the half blind dovetail.
I have some small speaker boxes I have to complete when time prevails that are built with through dovetails. Through dovetails present a good looking trapezoid profile on one side, yet a not as good looking rectangular profile on the opposing side. Through dovetails are still considered the pinnacle of fine woodworking.
Half blind dovetails present that same good looking and instantly recognizable trapezoid profile on one side. The opposing side is clean across its surface. It is a good look I think in addition to having just about as much prestige as its closely related through dovetail relative.
All of the three traditional box joinery techniques mentioned in this entry qualify for the appropriate strength requirement by presenting enough face grain surface area for gluing. I think I will use the half blind dovetail method on this project. It uniquely represents the principles of fine woodworking inherent in my work.
Molly is a singer and dancer in addition to being both friend and in this case client. One of her requirements is that the floor must be as light as possible yet built to minimum dimensions with certain materials that will enhance its resonant qualities.
My first design iteration had the box constructed of four side aprons joined to corner posts using mortise and tenon joinery. I was doing projects with that construction technique lately so it was natural to begin the design there. But that is not how a box is typically built.
The first true box iteration I explored was based on box joint construction. I built a couple of drawers and a few audio speaker system boxes using that method. I sometimes think of it as a signature style. But I think I am going to settle on another method that has worked well for me in the past. That method is the half blind dovetail.
I have some small speaker boxes I have to complete when time prevails that are built with through dovetails. Through dovetails present a good looking trapezoid profile on one side, yet a not as good looking rectangular profile on the opposing side. Through dovetails are still considered the pinnacle of fine woodworking.
Half blind dovetails present that same good looking and instantly recognizable trapezoid profile on one side. The opposing side is clean across its surface. It is a good look I think in addition to having just about as much prestige as its closely related through dovetail relative.
All of the three traditional box joinery techniques mentioned in this entry qualify for the appropriate strength requirement by presenting enough face grain surface area for gluing. I think I will use the half blind dovetail method on this project. It uniquely represents the principles of fine woodworking inherent in my work.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







.jpg)


