A blog devoted to professional aspects of design
and engineering applied to the art of fine woodworking.


February 22, 2015

Awesome Design and Existentialism

My Minnesota woodworking journey began with a small shop and more questions than ideas after I closed my organ building workshop back in Wisconsin. Art and structure were to be my primary focus though. That focus began to evolve with the design of a small ladder used for pipe organ tuning in close quarters.

Great results are produced by people who get to work and focus on their goals even when those goals are sometimes difficult to attain. And getting there can seem to be incredibly time consuming.

Something about the project I recently completed told me that I finally accomplished what I set out to with regard to art and structure. I feel confident in my ability to take my work to new levels now having a design architecture and the means to accomplish that architecture in place. The path was never completely clear though with an approach that often was way too go-it-alone most of the time. The photo above reminds me of that. I took it with a hand-me-down digital camera I had just obtained. The result seemed lonely and existential, probably enhanced by the way the light streams in on the cabinet doors.

I built the cabinet in the photograph during my early experience in woodworking to house kitchen plates and utensils. Utensils got their own drawer, and a separate section even houses glassware. The unique design of the cabinet with its multiple compartments makes it a favorite among friends.

I no longer feel that my workshop has to be the all consuming entity. I can find new roads with my work now. I feel like the journey is just beginning again.

January 14, 2015

The Walter Project and Organ Case Architecture

I had just closed my organ building workshop and moved to Minnesota. My plan here was to develop a woodworking shop to further my design skill by building smaller objects for what were back then, flourishing local art galleries. Something happened on the way to accomplishing that goal with the onset of the global financial crisis and accompanying deep recession. Gallery consignment sales practically dried up.

As my shop equipment stood standing practically still, I decided to solve a problem that bothered me when building those mechanical action pipe organs. I wanted to find a common scalable architecture that could house a series of small instruments in something that resembled a cabinet, yet was not a cabinet at all but namely, a framed structure. So I embarked on that journey by installing a solids modeling program on my laptop computer during the height of the recession, and began to simulate alternative frame-based structural designs that would result in an enclosed cabinet. Some people at this point might have made physical models out of wood, but considering that wood is relatively expensive, and the act of actually building things causes expensive tooling to dull and wear out, computer modeling looked like a thankfully welcome cost savings approach to take in a bad economy.

I developed what I now call my organ case architecture after a few months of computer design work that mostly took place in some coffee shops and a local pub or two around campus. It soon became clear that I would need to expand my workshop equipment to add capacity, and develop methods to actually build off this new architecture. My blog became a record of that journey as I developed and applied methods to trial and produce various techniques needed to build a structurally frame-based cabinet. One or two people who read it realized this, while others thought that I had turned my workshop into a small hobby space.

The project I just completed is the first to approximate my take on organ case architecture in a small cabinet design. I say approximate because it was altered somewhat to scale it down to an end-table sized object. A future project will scale up to something that fully incorporates the architecture as originally planned, and will put my adaptive shop to work on building a project I developed it to build.

This journey took a few years to complete, but if the cabinet photos here are any indication, the results are well worth the effort. I now have a design language from which to further develop and build both client and consignment work.

December 13, 2014

The Walter Project: A Design That Put It All Together

I just finished the major portion of shop work on a project that combined my concept of an adaptive workshop with a group technology build strategy. The adaptive shop concept allowed me to efficiently combine a number of diverse constructions into a single unified structure that makes a cohesive statement.

The schedule for this project was tight, and therefore, I decided early on to build it out of sequence using a take on group technology methods where similar components of somewhat unrelated assemblies are produced together to maximize build efficiency.

I accomplished this mainly by developing cut lists based not on a sequential assembly order, but on parts sorted by common construction technique and material size. It helped therefore to design with as much commonality as possible. Frames were made with 3/8" wide x 1 1/2" long mortise and tenon joints in 2" wide 5/4 stock for example. There were numerous panel glue ups not only for doors and side panels, but also drawer sides, fronts, and backs using 4/4 stock that were sorted into a single cut list and produced together.

Building this way allowed enough extra time in the project schedule to accommodate the construction of a rather interesting four-panel veneered top design, and the special open frame-left side doors that visually enclose the front and back of the cabinet, yet allow proper ventilation for a computer system the client intends to store within.

Building a design without regard to construction sequence requires a high degree of definition and planning up front that almost certainly negates evolution as the project progresses, evolution that often produces a better end result through the application of a builder's creative process. But I must admit that I often think about product design within the constraints of a shop that operates within a valid business model, and that requires a consideration of production rate and cost containment especially when the project is commissioned by a client as it was in this case.

Producing a design as an optimized family or group of woodworking processes may allow the balanced meshing of goals that include visual aesthetic, function, and reasonable profitability in a one-off project setting.

November 6, 2014

Another Organ Project: A First Step

A pipe organ is categorized as a wind instrument although it has a keyboard. Although all organs have at least one keyboard, the differences between instruments can be huge depending on the building style chosen. There are large industrial organs, and small historically based organs. I chose to build after a style based on the earlier history of the organ in its most simple and primitive form when mechanical action connected each key to its corresponding pipe valve. See the first pipe organ I built on that style here.

I modeled my keyboard design on several examples of eighteenth-century European organs I was fortunate enough to examine and play, and had an actual keyboard built to a 53-note specification some time ago by a German firm. I recently placed that keyboard on one of the shelving units I previously assembled in my workshop to get a better understanding of its relationship to the evolving design of a new pipe organ I intend to build as I work on other projects.

I think that every small shop owner must make decisions about what he or she can realistically build given resources available, and what should be jobbed out to another individual or firm. With respect to the organ, I find it unrealistic to gather the equipment needed to build either keyboards or metal organ pipes when there are others out there who can provide these items built to my standard and specifications just as I would want them built if I were doing it myself.

I recently computer modeled the 53-note keyboard in solids so that I can incorporate its design into new organ design assemblies. It in fact, was originally modeled in two-dimensions using AutoCad. Placing the keyboard on a shelving unit in my workshop allows me to visualize different organ design arrangements with regard to the minimalist concept I introduced in my last entry based on a reductionist approach, summed up well by Antoine de Saint Exupery, who said that perfection is attained not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing more to remove.

I may in the end modify that existing keyboard into something less than 53-notes, and I will occasionally play out a piece of music on it to see just how few notes would actually be required to perform something within the reasonable limitations of my new organ design. I made a recording some time ago of a short choral number on one of the church organs I built using just two of its stops and playing it down one octave, and discovered a unique and wonderful interpretation of that number even with the bass octave removed.

A short recording with two stops, less notes, and a new sound. Something to drive this project forward in fact.

October 24, 2014

Shelving Units: History, Perspective, and Pipe Organ Building

The Treaty of Versailles heavily restricted the German aircraft industry following WWI. Yet Germany was able to develop a bomber force prior to WWII by disguising their development as passenger aircraft. All good engineers are students of history because history often provides us with important lessons.

There is a good deal of discussion in music circles today about the current state of the pipe organ and its use. I feel that the instrument may no longer be relevant in a lot of ways just as I am beginning to define my workshop not only as a space to better understand functional design and the relevant architectures and technologies that produce that design through modern woodworking technique, but also as a place to continue the building of those musical instruments.

I began my shelving unit project to specifically prototype the construction of the sort of larger frames I would use to build another pipe organ according to a design concept I am working on where less is more. This instrument would be a smaller subset of one of the organs I built in the past yet, would be something altogether new providing those who use it with an instrument capable of expanding their knowledge of music, composition, improvisation, registration, and accompaniment by allowing them to incorporate a rich set of tonal resources into a performance with other musicians. Being a work of art in and of itself, I see something like this ending up in a smaller art or performance gallery where chamber music performances would enhance the use of the space.

It was Antoine de Saint Exupery who said that perfection is attained not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing more to remove. This is the basis for a pipe organ I would now build.

October 22, 2014

Shelving Units: The On Again, Off Again Project

The shelving units are a set of larger objects that will eventually go home with me. I fit their construction into the shop schedule when and where time allows. The design therefore experiences evolution. I had some spare time this past month to get two of the units assembled using a novel way of joining the shelves to the side frames with profiled mounts that allow some offset to take place which compensates for any small yet unavoidable dimensional tolerance errors that occurred during construction.

Meaning that everything went together really well during assembly.

I have a client project that I started a few days ago, so the shelving unit project is again on hold for the time being. Good thing too, because I now have a better idea formed for building the top sections using a profiled frame method that could turn out to be far more compelling than the simple solid wood tops currently applied to the two assembled units.

Building top sections for the shelving units will have to wait though, because newly commissioned work takes priority over anything else in this workshop.

September 24, 2014

Time to Catch Up

I can say what a great summer it was now that it's over. I completed the dance board project for a folk-indie music group, and a small but interesting speaker project. Both turned out to be personally rewarding in the outcomes they produced. The fall weather came early this September, and my thoughts instinctively turned to the possibility of yet another hard winter like the one we experienced last year when I started building my shelving unit project. Although the shelf unit side frames were completed, the actual shelf parts for that project were still stacked all around the shop. So it seemed natural to at least complete the shelves while I wait for word on yet another project design I recently submitted to a client for final approval.

The shelving unit project is a challenge in the shear number of operations it requires for each component assembly. It has given me a huge volume of experience in building large mortise and tenon joined frames in this relatively newly restructured workshop of mine.

They say that the weather should warm up by the end of the week. It may be an opportunity to take some time to get myself out of the shop, and take a short break from the work and sawdust. I think that might not be such a bad idea really.