A blog devoted to professional aspects of design
and engineering applied to the art of fine woodworking.


April 11, 2013

Developing Ideas in the Internet Age

A blog entry appeared in a major woodworking journal recently with regard to a change that has come about concerning the development of ideas, especially with new forms of social interaction brought about by Internet-based social networking. I actually wrote a comment.

The entry can be found here.

http://blog.woodshopnews.com/tbaw/?p=744

The writer's viewpoint is generally in favor of what is now normally referred to as crowdsourcing, where ideas are solicited from a group of people. This is obviously now much easier within Internet groups using Twitter, Facebook, or an online forum for example, and is a concept that has grown in popularity. Read any history about major inventions though, and one gets the idea that sharing ideas so freely wasn't always popular. Most famous inventors were at one time or another involved in a patent lawsuit against a competitor. In fact, patents are specifically awarded to protect someone who intends to materially profit from his or her own unique idea.

So now if someone crowdsources an idea though, then because ownership of that idea no longer belongs to any one individual, I suppose that any profit from that idea would have to come from the implementation of that idea through manufacture. Most practicing artisans I know are both proud and protective of the ideas that give their work its own identity. Ideas are intellectual property, so to me the idea of crowdsourcing may not apply to all people in all situations.

March 17, 2013

Industrial-Retro-Indie-Hipster-Techno Research-Based Woodworking

All of the words used in the title of this entry have been used at one point or another to describe whether in complete or partial truth the design statement my current work is making. There are projects that actually pay the bills, and then because the economy has slowed down that activity, there are projects that are producing a body of knowledge or at least are adding to it.

There are aspects to a project I have coming up that I need to understand more completely before actually committing resources toward building it, so I decided to create a series of simple objects to prototype those aspects and their associated construction methods. The original purpose of this prototype set involved the design use of tungsten filament light bulbs, but as the project evolved so too did the objects used to hold the bulbs.

Those objects are the end result of an evolutionary process as there were several iterations of each that came before I arrived at the final set you see here. Each design iteration had fewer parts as time went on, but those parts became increasingly complex to build as I described in an earlier entry. The most significant development I think that came from this project was in the direct use of design model geometry to graphically generate computer numerically controlled tool paths. An artisan studio or workshop is a high-mix, low-volume build environment, and being able to adapt methods quickly to different design requirements to achieve acceptable build time becomes more important if a business case is involved.

A good reference source for some of the underlying principles that I currently attempt to address through prototyping design work can be found at the website for the University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Quick Response Manufacturing.

March 10, 2013

The Incremental Cost of Part Complexity

I was introduced to parametric solids modeling about the time I completed building the pipe organ for Zion Lutheran. The leading program at that time was and still is SolidWorks. Although I wanted to use solids modeling then, I continued to use 2D computer drafting because of the high cost of 3D design programs including SolidWorks.

A few years ago, the cost of a reasonably well featured solids modeling program became low enough that I could justify incorporating it into my design work. Now I finally had a real engineering design program to use. The first thing I immediately noticed was a reduction in errors in the workshop. A good solids design requires that one accurately model each part and assembly, and having those represented in drawing format let me clearly see each part feature, and the relationship of each part to its parent assembly, in three dimensions. All of that helped me to build better in the workshop.

But something else happened that I did not count on. The parts I designed started becoming more complex. Parts began containing more features as parts started taking on more function within an assembly while the assemblies themselves began to have less parts overall. Look at the exploded view of the assembly above as an example. The assembly itself has only four parts. That seems simple enough. But look at the notched rail. That part is designed to hold a component mounted through the hole located along its top. The notches themselves locate the assembly along rails that are part of a larger assembly. And the two vertical slot mortises receive the tenons of two tenoned cross members that hold it all together.

Each of these features, the notches, hole, and mortises, must be accurately and sequentially machined until that one part is completed. The interesting thing I find now is that the cost of producing each feature is not simply the time it takes to machine that feature, but the additive cost of producing each preceding feature if a mistake is made while producing that feature. This is a problem because anyone who has done any woodworking knows that the activity is inherently error prone. A mistake at the end means having to go back and do a lot of work all over again, all the blade changes, tool setups, sizing, etc., and all for one part.

The projects that I've journaled here reflect an iterative change in part design and part to assembly relationship for me. All seem deceptively simple enough, but all are providing me with valuable experience in designing and building within a new paradigm. I've known others who have built in this style of complex efficiency and part economy especially among the German pipe organ builders. I find it an interesting and intelligent way to build.

March 1, 2013

The Alice Table: An Introduction

I recently received a commission to build a small side table for a client. Obviously that client's name is Alice. She asked me to build a table for her using teak so that it would match her current set of furniture. I suggested using walnut along with teak to keep cost reasonable. I often use more than one type of wood in my work to provide variation in color which should be obvious by now.

Alice has a degree in art education, and I kept this in mind as I did the design work making sure to use color and space well in an otherwise functional object. We went through a number of design iterations together by email before deciding on this open frame form. The design has two cross frames that connect the side frames to each other to break up what would have otherwise been open space. The design becomes more visually interesting while the cross frames support an inner shelf. Alice can use it to keep a book or magazine on while keeping the top clear for something more important. Like a glass of wine for instance.

Alice and I agreed on price and terms this week. Work will begin right after I complete building something to prototype several design and construction concepts to be used in another project. More on that in the following post.

February 11, 2013

Relevant LinkedIn News

LinkedIn periodically sends me an email with a list of links that it thinks I might be interested in. I received one such today with a number of links to articles that I thought were relevant to this blog.

The first links to an article written by Jeffrey Immelt and his thoughts on the future of productivity and the economy. Of particular interest to me was his take on reversing the trend of outsourcing and its detrimental effect on core competency. He also points to what I find is the compelling use of 3D printing as an advanced manufacturing process rather than how it is normally used as a design modeling tool.

The second covers some of the benefits of working at a coffee shop. All of us in academia whether faculty, staff, or student know how changing up an environment can support a particular effort or project. I took the photo above inside one of the coffee shops on campus that I frequent most often.

And the last is about the connection between the arts and science in education which is essentially what this blog is about, especially when you look at the nature of my work. Here below I provide links to these online articles.

1. Why We're Betting on Manufacturing

http://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20130207143128-230929989-why-we-re-betting-on-manufacturing?ref=email

2. Why You Should Work From a Coffee Shop, Even When You Have an Office

http://lifehacker.com/5979758/why-you-should-work-from-a-coffee-shop-even-when-you-have-an-office?utm_medium=linkedin&utm_source=dlvr.it&goback=.gde_49680_member_210306369

3. Education: The Focus on Science Shouldn't Make Us Forget the Arts

http://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20130207220042-10842349-creativity-s-role-in-education

December 31, 2012

Same But Different

Along with several posts written about the concepts and philosophy behind my design process and workshop layout, this blog has covered the construction of two rather simple projects this year. The first of these was an iPad stand, and the second is a set of candle holders I just completed this past weekend. The two projects pictured here appear different, but yet are almost the same.

Both designs have four tenoned legs that are glued into the slot mortises of a central block. That block in turn supports a platform that supports an item that needs holding. In one design that item is a candle. In the other that item is an iPad. Both designs appear almost identical from the perspective of the workshop, and so were therefore conceptually supported during their respective build processes quite successfully by the adaptive workcell arrangement around which I built my Minnesota shop.

There is much more to learn about manufacturing under the principles of Group Technology and the relationship that the broader concept of Design for Manufacturing has on producing a product family. I talked about common design architecture in an earlier post where I described a set of different lamp stands I built that were based on a common product platform architecture. The candle holders and iPad stand are just as much a product family based though on a common build architecture.

Update: I just completed building a set of objects to act as prototype fixtures for tungsten filament light bulbs. These are described in a later entry. You can see in the one whose photo I've added here that the concept of a central block with four tenoned legs is used yet again.

My walk in to work each morning usually takes me through the Mechanical Engineering building at the University of Minnesota. Two useful books on this topic that I found on the free book table there a couple of summers ago are listed below.

Meyer, M., & Lehnerd, A. (1997). The Power of Product Platforms. New York: The Free Press.
Sanderson, S., & Uzumeri, M. (1997). Managing Product Families. Chicago: Irwin.

I also found the following white paper a good source of recent information on this topic.

Parametric Technologies Corporation. (2012). Achieving Product Diversity with Scale.

The metal candle dishes for the candle holder project were provided by Marlaine Cox Metalworks.

December 2, 2012

And Then There Were Eight

Recall from my previous post that I am making a set of blocks for a Christmas project that each have four slot mortises routed on one face, and a circular extruded cut feature routed on the other.

The slot mortises were easy to rout using the CNC router, and since they will accept a matching tenon, they only needed to be accurate.

The circle features on the other hand need to be free of visual defect which I found more difficult to accomplish given the nature of the two woods I am using.

Padauk and zebrawood easily splinter, and the router bit also tends to burn both woods more easily than others. I found that slowing the speed of the router to somewhere around 12,000 rpm and increasing the feed rate of the cut removed any tendency of the router bit to burn the wood. It was actually surprising that this combination of speed and feed rate also produced an almost splinter free cut.

What a relief.

There were originally nine blocks. The problem of speed and feed rate did not appear on the initial test run using a scrap of medium density fiberboard. It only became apparent on the first block of zebrawood.

This unfortunately happens sometimes.

That first block of zebrawood is now a block of sacrificial scrap. It was used to perfect the cnc routing process for the circles, and will be useful to test a future process that might need verification before committing that process to the other eight blocks.